Top 5 Best Mascara For Sensitive Eyes That Does Not Smudge

Your holy grail on the best mascara for sensitive eyes revealed

By Aey
Top 5 Best Mascara For Sensitive Eyes That Does Not Smudge

Why you should invest in a mascara

Makeup is the way to make most of our souls happy and mascaras are the holy grails of our makeup bags. If you think even for a second, that mascaras are not important for your everyday looks then we have to stop you right there and bring you back to the path of sanity! Who does not want long eyelashes and wide-eyed looks, both which come from your mascara application? More than that, mascara can give you a dabbed eye shadow look and at the same time can ensure a bright-eyed morning! So, do your lashes a favor and keep on reading to discover amazing products that will give your lashes a makeover.

2019 Best Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Drugstore Mascara for Sensitive Eyes and Contact Wearers



Organic wear® Natural Origin Work it! Full! Flared! Fit! Mascara

When it comes to finding products with the least harmful effects, physician’s formula has ensured to keep its overall reputation intact throughout for all its customers. Just like that when it comes to mascara, it ensures to provide different products for all its different customers. It ensures to take a step forward to provide its customers with sensitive eyes a way out. It further makes certain to have the back of its contact wearer customers as well!

What it is

Physicians’ formula brings to you its famous, richly pigmented and volume enhancer, Organic Wear Natural Origin Work it Mascara and that too just for $10.49. Being waterproof, gym proof and sweat proof; this mascara tends to stand up to humid weathers and heat in the busiest of days! This mascara provides you with a lusher, plusher and on top of it all a dramatic look whilst protecting your eyes at the same time!

How safe is it

Not only does this mascara promise to give you a great Bambi look, it further ensures not to do any harm to your eyes. This mascara has a unique blend of kale, carrots, quinoa, and protein which ensures to improve hair elasticity and strengthens the lashes. It is not just gluten-free but is further hypoallergenic & ophthalmologist tested thus making it perfect for all contact wearers and sensitive eyes people out there.

Beauty tip

Start from the lash roots and wiggle the wand up to the tips and repeat. Then hold the wand vertically for your lower lashes and repeat.

2. Maybelline Full 'N Soft Mascara


Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara - Eye Makeup - Maybelline

Maybelline has promising products from BB creams to foundations & mascaras and so on and so forth. The key for finding the good mascara is not just the mascara itself but it is also highly dependent on how you apply that mascara through its literal magic wand. The right move and the right stroke will always provide you with the right look. Maybelline ensures to first fulfill your need of the right wand so you can turn towards the best possible looks.

What it is

Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Mascara is a product high in demand with the best reviews in the market. The hypoallergenic formula makes its one of the best products for people with sensitive eyes and further for contact wearers as well. For a price as low as $8, this mascara as the name suggests leaves behind a full yet soft look with its perfect wand.

How safe is it

As mentioned above, this is a hypoallergenic formula which is further advanced with the help of a vitamin E formula for thickening eyelashes. It is further a volumizing mascara that is washable and its ophthalmologist testation ensures for it to be completely safe for contact wearers. It helps to prevent your lovely long eyelashes from falling out too!

Beauty tip

Start sweeping the brush from the roots of your lashes till your tip and repeat. Remember to not let your mascara dry in between coats to avoid lumps.

3. L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara

Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara - L'Oréal Paris

L’Oréal is one of those products which have been around for a while and is trusted completely by their consumers. Whether it’s the brand selling cosmetics or whether it’s the brand selling toiletries, the fact remains that it ensures never to let its customers down. So, from great shampoos to give you the best nourishing and long hair, it ensures through ‘L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara’ to give you the absolute best, nourishing and volumizing eyelashes.

What it is

The L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara is a game-changing and innovative mascara which aims to provide its users with a lash extension effect and further provides an 80 percent longer looking and nurtured lash look. For a price as low as $10.95, it is available in a shade of ‘black’ and a further shade of ‘blackest black’.

How safe is it

This ophthalmologist and allergy tested mascara is great for people with sensitive eyes and contact wearers. It further makes sure to protect your lashes through its smudge proof and easily washable quality. The product is infused with Ceramide R and D-Panthenol which not just protects your lashes but also further strengthens them.

Beauty tip

The best way to use this product is by using the white end to prime your eyelashes and the black end to then further move towards building upon the length of your lashes. Apart from that, just use water when removing the mascara as it will come off easily and quickly without any issues i.e. smudging.

4. Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

Healthy Lengths Mascara | Neutrogena®

Whenever we hear about the brand Neutrogena, we automatically assume the product to be medicated and if not completely medicated then to be completely safe at the least. From their great acne face washes till their health length mascaras, Neutrogena has some of the best products for all its customers. Just like that, another great product of theirs is their Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara.

What it is

The Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara is lash lengthening mascara which aims to not just give you a volumizing look but also ensures to strengthen your eyelashes from the inside out. Refusing to blotch, cluster or flake, this $8.99 mascara gives you a standout look. Consumer tested reports show this mascara to extend lashes up to twice their length upon application!

How safe is it

Being a Neutrogena product, this mascara is ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested making it perfect for people with sensitive eyes and those wearing contact lenses. It further has a vitamin E and olive oil formula that doesn’t only nourish the eyelashes but also strengthens them.

Beauty tip

Start from the very base of your eyelashes and then move up towards the tip and repeat. The wand carries gentle bristles which ensure to comb through each and every lash thus applying anti-oxidants to each strand giving a heavier look along with an intensified color.

5. Almay One Coat Thickening Mascara

Source: : Almay One Coat Thickening Mascara, Blackest Black, 0.4 Fluid Ounce : Beauty

Almay is a cosmetic brand owned by our very own and very favorite brand and company ‘Revlon’. The question that you might have is why did Revlon open a completely separate brand and didn’t launch these products under its very own ‘Revlon’ umbrella? The fact is that the company has dedicated this line of the brand to create products catering to people with sensitive skin and no surprise they ensured to make mascara covering our makeup needs.

What is it?

For over a period of 80 years Almay has dedicated it’s time to make sure that all its products are hypoallergenic and also completely pure. This one coat thickening mascara aims to provide you with a volumizing and thicker look with just one clump-free application. Being marketed in black and blackest black, this product is available at a price of $9.99 and $7.49 respectively. 

How safe is it?

This mascara is one of the best, clean, pure and hypoallergenic mascaras for sensitive eyes and contact wearers out there. It is free of fragrance and is ophthalmologist tested enriched with aloe and vitamin B5. The refusal of the mascara to smudge or clump further makes it a perfect buy for sensitive eyes.

Beauty tip

Start from the roots of the eyelashes and then move towards the tip.

Related Article: How to care for Mascara Brush In The Right Way After Using
How to care for Mascara Brush In The Right Way After Using
Give your mascara brushes a longer life span with proper cleaning


No matter how sleepy or tired you look, mascaras can change your look around completely and it would be unfair to us if we, contact wearers or people with sensitive eyes, don’t get to reap the benefits of mascara. Thus, this detailed discussion ensures to look out for all customers and makes sure the holy grail of your makeup bag is not left behind!