List of 8 Best Natural Mascaras That Does Not Harm Your Eyes

Put on these best natural mascaras on your lashes with no worries

By Caren M
List of 8 Best Natural Mascaras That Does Not Harm Your Eyes

What Are Considered Natural Mascaras?

Mascara is one of the arsenals of eye makeup that have been in existence since the start of civilization. A mascara’s main work is making sure your lashes are the talk of the town by adding length, volume, and drama to your lashes.

Mascara is one of those beauty products that you don’t need a master's in makeup application to make it work and it can work all on its own (Doesn’t require complimentary makeup) and it will instantly make your eyes look more awake and full of life.

Natural Mascaras

Natural mascaras are the opposite of the synthetic, chemical-filled mascaras that currently dominate the makeup world. Chemical-based mascaras contain synthetic products such as parabens, synthetic dyes, formaldehyde, propylene glycol, and polybutene, just to mention a few, that may be harmful to the sensitive skin around your eyes with continued use. 

For this reason, more and more people are making the leap into natural mascaras. Natural mascaras are made of mostly natural products like beeswax or extracting ingredients from various plants.

It should be noted however that most natural mascaras still contain chemicals such as preservatives to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria, especially in water-based products. Chemists now have been able to come up with antimicrobial ingredients like fermented radish and cellulose but these have not yet hit the market fully so you might have to endure a few select synthetics in your natural mascara for a while longer.

That being said, the world is mostly going green and makeup is not being left behind! Although traditionally all-natural mascara has been looked down upon because of all its flaws like either being too wet or too dry, or not being inky enough but some of the later products have really turned the tide around and now people that like natural products can go for some of our favorite natural mascaras picks in the market right now.

2019 Best Natural Mascaras Brands That Are Waterproof

1. Kjaer Weis Mascara

Kjaer Weis Mascara

This mascara comes with an attractive classic design that will add that look of serious class to your makeup collection, but down to the reasons why we have a hard-on for this product: It is made of completely natural and organic products, making up about 99.8% of the total ingredients so you can rest your pretty green heart. It has a super-stay inky pigmented product to lengthen and add volume to your lashes. It also has a tiny lash-grabbing wand to make sure no lashes are left out when coating them with this go-green goodness and a flat side on the handle to make application easier.

2. Well People Expressionist Mascara

Mascara Expressionist

These warriors of the green came up with this edgy product that like their lashes to look spectacular but still have a nature-conscious heart and it lives up to the expectations of its users. It has an amazing brush that looks like a small football that gets lashes to their fullest length in one go. It, however, has no film formers so you should wait for it to dry then set it with a translucent powder.

3. Honest Beauty Mascara+ primer

Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara

This wonder-worker is a combination of both primer and mascara to make sure you get the best of both worlds for stunning lush length, volume, and definition. The primer coats the lashes to create an even base and intensify color while the mascara lays down in a silky smooth way to provide incredible lift and sky-high lift for your lashes. The brush is designed with special bristles to pick up every lash for that amazing definition and finish you’re looking for.

4. Bert’s Bees Mascara

Burt's Bees 100% Natural Mascara

Their mascara is synthetic-free and instead contains pullulan to prevent flaking and water-smudging. It works to lengthen, define and add volume to your eyes. It contains jojoba oil and moisturizing glycerin that wears for long and can last you a day without flaking or clumping up.

5. Antonym Lola Lash Too Mascara

Antonym mascara is made of 98% naturally derived ingredients for long, well-defined lashes that have the volume and lift you need. What’s more, it has quite a nice shiny black pigmentation and is waterproof and can, therefore, withstand some sad sappy movie or a good sweaty day.

Antonym Lola Lash TOO Mascara

6. Juice Beauty lash defining mascara

Juice Beauty Ultra-Natural Mascara

The formula provides a super inky finish and the brush, shaped like a cone, creates long and separated lashes without making them look too thick and reaches the hard-to-get-to corner lashes with one easy sweep. Its hydrating ingredients keep it from flaking.

7. Naturally Rooted Premium Organic Mascara

Premium Organic Mascara

Made of 85% natural ingredients, this product is cruelty-free, making it an excellent choice for naturalists and vegans that like to look good while they save the planet. It creates beautiful lashes with its parabens, dye, and gluten-free ingredients and is a good choice for people with sensitive skin.

It also strengthens and conditions lashes with chamomile and sunflower oil for naturally sleek, long and shiny lashes that look great even without makeup. The rich black color makes your lashes bold and beautiful and is long-lasting and waterproof.

8. 100% pure blackberry Pigmented mascara

100% Pure Mascara, Blackberry

This product is 100 percent derived from blackberries so you already know it smells good. The blackberry hue gives off a slightly chrome/ purple color that looks so beautiful people will want a second look just to confirm. The curved brush gives nice length and contains vitamin B5, Vitamin E, oat seed oil, plus other natural ingredients to strengthen and condition your lashes, making them the talk of the town.

Top 3 Natural Mascara Removers For Sensitive Eyes

After a day of slaying in your mascara and having people comment nonstop about how good your eyes look, you need to take care of your skin but taking all that makeup off.

We don’t need to go into details about how damaging sleeping in your make up is for your skin, including clogged pores, dull-looking skin, and breakouts- yikes!- so you need to invest in a good makeup remover, especially for the eye region.

Standard chemical removers may contain really harsh ingredients that end up drying out your skin and breaking down the moisture barrier, leaving your skin looking worse for wear. Enter natural mascara removers that are much kinder to the skin and are friendly to the environment.

1. Jojoba oil

Cliganic Organic Jojoba Oil

Jojoba oil is already a skincare giant on its own with about a million and one benefits for healthy skin. It is rich in vitamins A, E and D and antioxidants and fatty acids so it treats your skin while removing the most stubborn of makeup including waterproof mascara. Dab a bit on your lashes and wait for it to penetrate and then clean off with a ball of clean cotton wool.

2. Sweet almond oil

Viva Naturals Sweet Almond Oil

This is another veteran oil in the skincare and beauty world that has a whole lot of advantages to the skin and is even better for people with sensitive skin. It has similar properties to jojoba oil; vitamins A, E and will perform a deep cleanse without breaking you out.

3. We love eyes Natural makeup remover

All Natural Tea Tree Eye Makeup Remover Oil

Soothes and relieves dry, itchy eyes by removing allergens, makeup debris and other sources of inflammation with all-natural, vegan ingredients such as tea tree oil, jojoba oil, and grapeseed oil, to keep your eyes feeling white and bright. It’s fragrance and chemicals free to remove stubborn waterproof mascara while maintaining your skin in its good natural condition.

Related Article: Tips on How to Apply Mascara With Eyelash Extensions
Tips on How to Apply Mascara With Eyelash Extensions
Is it okay to apply mascara when you have lash extensions?


The main advantage of using natural mascara is that it’s going to be super gentle on your skin because it’s made of products that you actually use. 

We hope that this guide tempts you enough to try out one of the products- or eight! because we promise you’ll be hooked just like we are!